Aruba vacation and travel information on Aruba hotels, beaches, restaurants and so much more

Go Back   Aruba Forums at Visit Aruba > Aruba Timeshare & Vacation Properties > Timeshare Q&A

Timeshare Q&A General questions about timeshares.

Thread Tools Display Modes
Old Monday, November 19th, 2007, 06:48 PM
89checkmate22 89checkmate22 is offline
Join Date: October 22nd, 2007
Location: West Union, SC
Posts: 35
89checkmate22 is on a distinguished road
I Love Aruba RCI Class Action Suits

Today I received an unsolicited mailing from Timeshare Relief, Inc., of Torrance CA that contained an article that, as a timeshare owner (but not with RCI) I thought current and potential Aruba timeshare owners would find interesting. The author is Katheren Dickinson and here is the article in its entirety:

Timeshare owners enrolled in the exchange program with RCI have grown increasingly frustrated by the unavailability of equitable timeshare trades. This frustration has culminated in two separate class action lawsuits being filed in New Jersey on March 14, 2006, both suits alleging RCI allows improper rentals and is committing fraud.

In the case filed in the United States District Court for New Jersey, the Complainant, Murillo, accuses RCI of marketing its program to RCI memebers as though they are the only ones to have access to the deposited timeshare weeks. The lawsuit summary introduction alleges, "As RCI tells it, each member can deposit his or her timeshare with RCI - thereby making it available for other members of the program - and can then withdraw a timeshare [that] another member has deposited. A key selling point is that only members of the program can access the deposited timeshares. This concept of a one-for-one exchange exclusively among RCI members is RCI's bedrock marketing principle. Unfortunately, RCI creates this image of its program through a uniform fraudulent, deceptive and unconscionable marketing scheme." On RCI's home website, it states "One of the most significant benefits of RCI subscribing membership is the ability to exchange into one of the many RCI affiliated resorts...Exchange Vacations are a great solution when you need to change the annual weeks you've been assigned at your resort. Simply deposit that week with RCI and choose a vacation at a time and place that works for you." The process sounds remarkably easy, but unfortunately for the RCI members, they're finding it anything but. Comments regarding the lawsuit that were sent in to "Timesharing Today" magazine vary from, "I have suspected precisely what is being alleged against RCI. I hope someone nails them good" to "Three cheers for the lawsuit," and "May I be in the complaint, residing in Maryland?"

This backlash is because members are realizing that using the program isn't nearly as simple as RCI claims it is. The lawsuit further alleges that "In practice, the RCI members are not the only persons with access to the timeshares. While RCI members deposit their timeshares into the system, RCI does not make all these timeshares available for exchange. Instead, RCI skims a large percentage of the timeshares from the system, including many prime timeshares, and rents these out to the general public for profit. RCI also uses these timeshares for promotional purposes and as fringe benefits for its employees, further depleting the number of timeshares available for member exchanges." Unlike any normal banking procedure where a customer can make a withdrawal equal to a deposit, people who bank their weeks hoping to exchange their time for time of equal value are unable to regardless of following normal and expected usage protocol.

The detrimental consequences to the majority of RCI members are plenty. As outlined in the lawsuit, "Through these and other business practices, RCI converts many of the prime timeshare deposits into cash, leaving much less desirable timeshares in the system for member exchanges. As a result of these fraudulent practices, the actual exeriences of many RCI members is that no matter how meticulously they follow RCI's rules and procedures, no matter how far in advance they begin looking for an exchange, they simply cannot find any comparable exchanges. RCI profits by these practices at the expense of its members, whose timeshares and RCI "benefits" are rendered virtually worthless."

Even more exasperating is the commonly held belief that RCI is involved in agreements with travel vendors further depleting available timeshare exchanges for paying RCI members. This allegation is made by both the Murillo Complaint, and also the Chase class action suit filed in New Jersey Superior Court. The claims are that "RCI secretly enters into agreements with third-party vendors who purchase high-demand timeshare weeks which had been deposited by members and resell them to the general public through various websites, while concealing any relationship with RCI," and that "RCI, despite its public pronouncements to the contrary, uses weeks deposited by members to provide inventory for its various affiliated rental programs." Because the allegations in these cases are similar, it's likely that they will be consolidated into one case, and both have already been assigned to the same Judge. RCI has only commented that their "policy is not to comment on matters in litigation." For more information visit

I don't know which resorts in Aruba that sell timeshares are affiliated with RCI, but this is a good case of "buyer beware". It makes one wonder if Interval International and the others are participating in the same practices, doesn't it? I guess the only advice I can give is that if you LOVE ARUBA (as we do) and want to go back year after year (as we do), then timeshare ownership is the ticket. Otherwise, caveat emptor.
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
Old Wednesday, November 21st, 2007, 04:03 PM
PhoenixGirl PhoenixGirl is offline
Aruba Expert
Join Date: September 14th, 2004
Location: Houston Texas
Posts: 284
PhoenixGirl is on a distinguished road
I Love Aruba Re: RCI Class Action Suits

Even if you love Aruba and always want to use your timeshares, there are often circumstances where you need to switch your weeks to other ones later in the year. This just happened when my husband had emergency surgery on his leg prior to traveling last month. We deposited our weeks, but Lord knows if we will be able to reschedule them and get any kind of exchange.

I hope this lawsuit will stop the practice of RCI renting out the deposited weeks. I know it is very hard to get Aruba and now I know why.
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:20 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright 2006 -2011 -